Sixties Scoop Class Action: Brown v. Canada, 2017 ONSC 251

The Ontario Superior Court of Justice issued its decision this morning (February 14, 2017)  in the Ontario Sixties Scoop class action.

The court held that the Federal Crown owed and breached a “common law duty of care to take reasonable steps to prevent on-reserve Indian children in Ontario, who had been placed in the care of non-aboriginal foster or adoptive parents, from losing their aboriginal identity” (Brown v Canada, 2017 ONSC 251, at para 85).

The full court decision is available on The Globe and Mail website and will be available on CanLII later this week.

An archived stream of the ceremonial sharing of the decision at the Native Child and Family Services of Toronto with the representative plaintiff Chief Marcia Martel is available for viewing here.

On February 1, 2017 the Federal Government announced that it would seek to negotiate a national settlement to the “Sixties Scoop litigation’. The full press release can be found on the Government of Canada’s website.

For more background information on the Sixties Scoop, below are a few items in UVic Libraries’ collection:

  • A History of Adoption Law in Ontario, 1921 – 2015 (Chapter 9: Indigenous Children and Adoption) – Lori Chambers. Call number: KEO228 C53 2016 (Law Library)
  • A Generation Removed : The Fostering and Adoption of Indigenous Children in the Postwar World (Chapter 6: The Indigenous Child Welfare Crisis in Canada)- Margaret Jacobs. Call number: HV875.6 J33 2014 (McPherson Library)
  • Moving Toward Positive Systems of Child and Family Welfare (Chapter 3: Aboriginal Child Welfare) – eds. Gary Cameron, Nick Coady, and Gerald R. Adams. Online
  • A literature review and annotated bibliography on aspects of Aboriginal child welfare in Canada
    – Marlyn Bennett, Cindy Blackstock and Richard De La Ronde. Online.
  • Stolen from our Embrace : The Abduction of First Nations Children and the Restoration of Aboriginal Communities – Suzanne Fournier and Ernie Crey. Call number: E78 C2 F675 (McPherson Library)
  • Four Decades of Child Welfare Services to Native Indians in Ontario: A Contemporary Attempt to Understand the ‘Sixties Scoop’ in Historical, Socioeconomic and Political Perspective – Joyce Barbara Timpson. Online
  • Governing Childhood (Chapter V: Therapies of Freedom: The Colonization of Aboriginal Childhood) – Anne McGillivray. Call Number: HQ789 G658 (McPherson Library)
  • Richard Cardinal : Cry from a Diary of a Métis Child – National Film of Canada. Streaming video.
  • Native Children and the Child Welfare System – Patrick Johnston. Call number: E78 C2 J63 (Law Library)
  • No Quiet Place : Final Report Review Committee on Indian and Metis Adoptions and Placements – Edwin C Kimelman. Call Number: KF8210 C45 M36 1985 (Law Library)

 

 

 

Family Day closure and research help during reading week

Please note that the Law Library will be closed next Monday, February 13 (Family Day). Full details of our hours of operation are available here.

While the research help desk will be closed during reading week –  research and citation help will remain available during reading week.

Students, you’re encouraged to email or phone the usual research help contacts. The librarians receive email and phone messages at those contacts and will respond as quickly as possible, Monday through Friday. You may also make an appointment with a librarian for research help via email or the staff at the library loan desk.

Our regular Research Help Desk hours will resume on Monday, February 20.

Live Stream: State of Washington v Trump

The US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit is set to hear oral arguments at 3:00 pm PST on whether the federal district court’s temporary nationwide injunction barring the enforcement of President Trump’s executive order on immigration should remain in place.

Oral arguments will be live streamed on the US Court of Appeals’ website at 3:00 pm PST. Students and faculty interested in listening to oral arguments can listen here. If anyone is unable to listen this afternoon, the hearing will also be archived and made available  by 12:00 pm PST on Wednesday, February 8. The archived hearing will be posted to the court’s YouTube channel here.

The court has also made available the parties’ written briefs and all amicus curiae briefs. All briefs are available on the court’s website.

CanLII: New Content and Improvements

Canada’s free case law and legislation database keeps getting better.

CanLII recently announced that it has added 12,000 pre-1980 decisions from the Dominion Law Reports (DLR). This is in addition to the 4,000 pre-1980 DLR decisions that CanLII added back in September bringing the total of pre-1980 DLR decisions on CanLII to 16,000.

These weren’t the only case law additions that CanLII made this year, CanLII also expanded its Quebec case law collection to include:

  • Decisions published between 1983 and 1996 in the Recueils de droit judiciare;
  • Decisions published between 1994 and 2004 in the Répertoire électronique de jurisprudence du Barreau; and
  • Select decisions published between 1869 and 1969 in the Revue légale.

CanLII also made additions to its legislation collection adding Annual Statutes of Canada (2001 – present) and the Quebec Annual Statutes (1996 to present).

CanLII also improved its ‘Find in document’ feature allowing users to change the words in the document that they want highlighted.

You can read more about the new case law additions and technological improvements on the CanLII Blog.

New Titles in the Law Library

Watch this space regularly for updates of new print and electronic titles received in or for the law library. We’ll supply the author, title, and call number information, as well as a link to the catalogue record where you can find out more about each title.

  • Criminal conspiracies: organized crime in Canada – Margaret E. Beare. Call Number: HV6807 B42 2015
  • Property diversity and its implications – John Page. Call Number: K720 P34 2017
  • Managing Babel: the international legal protection of minorities in the twentieth century – Li-ann Thio. Call Number K3242 T47 2005
  • Indivisible: indigenous human rights – edited by Joyce Green. Call Number: K3247 I556
  • Contesting medical confidentiality: origins of the debate in the United States, Britain, and Germany – Andreas-Holger Maehle. Call Number: K3611 C65M34 2016
  • Leading the way: Canadian women in the law – Julie Soloway. Call Number: KE332 W6S64 2015
  • Fast track: a legal, historical and political analysis – Hal S. Shapiro. Call Number: KF6659 S53 2006
  • Stability and change in the law of the sea: the role of the LOS convention – edited by Alex G. Oude Elferink. Call Number: KZA1120.3 J19 2004
  • Bringing new law to ocean waters – edited by David D. Caron and Harry N. Scheiber. Call Number: KZA1141 B75 2004
  • The purse and the sword: the trials of Israel’s legal revolution – Daniel Friedmann; translated by Haim Watzman. Call Number: KMK2244 F7513 2016

Reconciliation Syllabus Blog: 2016 Clawbie Runner-up

The Reconciliation Syllabus Blog, established in the summer of 2015 by  UVic Law professor Rebecca Johnson and Associate Dean Gillian Calder, was recently named runner-up for best Canadian law blog in the category of Change and Advocacy.  Writing about the Reconciliation Syllabus blog, the Clawbies noted:

‘We’d be hard-pressed to name a more important and timely conversation in Canadian legal education in 2016 than this one. This collaborative blog is “a Truth & Reconciliation Commision-inspired gathering of materials for teaching law”, where law professors and others reflect on and share concrete examples of how best to respond to TRC Call to Action #28.’

You can read more about the Reconciliation Syllabus blog and the Clawbies on UVic Law’s news and events page.

For more information about the Clawbies and the other 2016 blog winners, check out the Clawbies website.

Congratulations Professors Johnson and Calder!

Reduced hours and holiday closure

Congratulations, students, on completing your fall term, papers and exams.

Please note the library’s reduced hours and holiday closure:

Monday, Dec 19 to Thursday, Dec 22

Friday, Dec 23

8:30 am to 4:00 pm

8:30 am to 2:00 pm

Saturday, Dec 24, 2016 to Monday, Jan 2, 2017 UNIVERSITY HOLIDAY CLOSURE
Tuesday, Jan 3 2017 regular hours resume

Check or bookmark the UVic Libraries’ hours and location page for ongoing details of our hours of operation.

And remember, UVic law students, you need not be away from the law library even if you are away from campus during the break. If you find yourself longing for a look at one of our licensed databases, off-campus access is available to you throughout this time, as always. Simply access the libraries’ database list, and enter your netlink ID and password when prompted to do so.

Enjoy your well-deserved break, and we’ll see you back in 2017.

Research help during the December exam period

You may have noticed that the research help desk in the law library is unattended during the December exam period.

Though the desk is quiet, research and citation help will remain available until December 23.

Students, you’re encouraged to email or phone the usual research help contacts. The librarians receive email and phone messages at those contacts and will respond as quickly as possible, Monday through Friday. You may also make an appointment with a librarian for research help via the staff at the library circulation desk.

Our regular reference help Desk hours will commence again in the new year.

 

New Titles in the Law Library

Watch this space regularly for updates of new print and electronic titles received in or for the law library. We’ll supply the author, title, and call number information, as well as a link to the catalogue record where you can find out more about each title.

  • FinTech innovation: from robo-advisors to goal based investing and gamification – Paolo Sironi. Call Number: HG173 S57 2016
  • Albion’s fatal tree: crime and society in eighteenth-century England – Douglas Hay. Call Number: HV6946 A54 2011
  • Law after modernity – Sionaidh Douglas-Scott. Call NumberK236 D68 2013
  • Unjust enrichment – James Edelman and Elise Bant. Call Number: K920 E34 2016
  • Whistleblowing law – Edited by Robert G. Vaughn. Call Number: K1773 W485 2015
  • Marine mammal conservation and the law of the sea – Cameron S. G. Jefferies. Call Number: K3525 J44 2016
  • Cases of conflict: transboundary disputes and the development of international environmental law – Allen L. Springer. Call Number: 3 S67 2016
  • Exploring the mandatory life sentence for murder – Barry Mitchell. Call Number: KD7885 I6M58 2012
  • The law of employee monitoring in Canada – Melanie R. Bueckert. Call Number: KE3328 B84 2016
  • The constitutions that shaped us: a historical anthology of pre-1867 Canadian constitutions – Edited by Guy Laforest. Call Number: KE4199 C4713 2015
  • Judicious restraint: the life and law of Justice Marshall E. Rothstein – General editors, Lisa M. Kelly, Ivo Entchev. Call Number: KE8248 R67J83 2016
  • The beginning and end of rape: confronting sexual violence in Native America – Sarah Deer. Call Number: KIE3560 D44 2015
  • Religion, law, and intolerance in Indonesia – edited by Tim Lindsey and Helen Pausacker. Call Number: BL640 R335 2016
  • Legal pluralism and development: scholars and practitioners in dialogue – Edited by Brian Z. Tamanaha, Caroline Sage, Michael Woolcock. Call Number: K236 L44 2013
  • Lawyers’ empire: legal professions and cultural authority, 1780-1950 – W. Wesley Pue. Call Number: KD460 P83 2016
  • Doctrine of res judicata in Canada – Donald J. Lange. Call Number: KE8514 L36 2015
  • Drugs law and legal practice in Southeast Asia: Indonesia, Singapore and Vietnam – Tim Lindsey and Pip Nicholson. Call Number: KNC691 L56 2016
  • Ross on crime – Mirko Bagaric; original author David Ross, QC. Call Number: KU3797.3 B34 2016

250th Anniversary of World’s First Freedom of Information Law

Today marks the 250th anniversary of the world’s first freedom of information law. In 1766 Sweden’s legislature enacted the Freedom of the Print Act which abolished censorship of books and newspapers and required government to provide public access to administrative and judiciary documents.

Information about the 1766 Act, including an English translation of the Act, is available the Swedish National Library’s website: https://frittord250.se/in-english/

Check out a few of the titles on FOI laws in Canada in UVic Libraries’ collection:

  • Government information : the right to information and protection of privacy in Canada – Kris Klein and Denis Kratchanov. Call number: KE5325 K53 2009
  • Access to information and social justice : critical research strategies for journalists, scholars, and activists – edited by Jamie Brownlee and Kevin Walby. Call number: JL86 S43A23
  • National freedom of information audit – Fred Vallance-Jones, Emily Kitagawa. Online
  • Striking the right balance for transparency : recommendations to modernize the Access to Information Act – Office of the Information Commissioner of Canada. Online
  • Brokering access : power, politics, and freedom of information process in Canada – Edited by Mike Larsen and Kevin Walby. Call number: KE5325 B76 2012
  • Fundamentals of privacy and freedom of information in Canada – Michel W. Drapeau, Marc-Aurèle Racicot. Call number: KE5325 D737 2010
  • Access to information legislation in Canada and four other countries – Kristen Douglas. Online.